British Argument For Elgin Marbles

Another argument for keeping the parthenon marbles within the uk has been made by j.

British argument for elgin marbles.

This argument is based on the assertion that lord elgin committed an illegal act when he removed the sculptures from the parthenon and exported them to britain in the early 1800s. The british defend their ownership of the marbles based on greece s lack of an adequate museum and the fact that they paid for the pieces mcguigan 2. He has argued that the elgin marbles have been in england since 1821 and in that time have become a part of the british cultural heritage. Argument for the return of elgin marbles to greece.

See the full poll results. They argue that british have not cared for the marbles properly. Many of the arguments for and against appeal to emotion and generate anger rather than being rational. Uppernorwood said 09 06 18 at 8 06 am.

Merryman sweitzer professor of law at stanford university and co operating professor in the stanford art department. It is often said that the parthenon sculptures belong to the world. All over the globe there are committees for the. Lord elgin received a firman a royal mandate or decree issued by the sovereign in historical islamic states from the sultan which permitted the removal of the marbles.

Lord elgin rescued the marbles by removing them to safety in britain an argument consistently promoted by the british museum and supported by julien anfruns director general of the international council of museums icom. In some cases excessive rubbing and polishing had not only destroyed the sculptures historic surfaces but deformed them to a shocking degree. The trustees of the. Indeed in the late 1930s it is known that the.

They further bolster their argument claiming that western culture including britain is a product of greek antiquity thus the elgin marbles are part of british history as well the british museum 2. British damage to elgin marbles irreparable. Only a few years after elgin took the marbles. Greece wants its treasured elgin marbles back from the british.

As the british museum s website states lord elgin acted with the full knowledge and permission of the legal authorities of the day when many in britain questioned the legality of this action when the marbles first arrived a parliamentary select committee investigated the claims and subsequently found in 1816 that. The director of the british museum has provoked anger by suggesting the removal of the parthenon marbles from greece in the 19th century could be seen as a creative act. Argument for the return of elgin marbles to greece case study example.